Japanese investors found undervalued stocks using Price-to-Book Value. Can we find such bargains on the ASX?

Japanese stocks have been rising as share prices catch up with book values
Can Price-Book Value ratio identify undervalued stocks?
We take a look at ASX stocks with best Price-Book Value ratios

Japanese stocks are scaling heights not seen since 1989, outpacing gains in other developed markets including the S&P 500.

There are theories on why there is a sudden interest in Nikkei stocks, particularly when the Japanese economy has been stagnant for the best past of 30 years.

According to Schroders, one trigger could have been the Tokyo Stock Exchange’s (TSE) call in March for companies to focus on enhancing corporate value.

This call was particularly directed at companies with a price-to-book (P/B) ratio of below 1.

The TSE had asked companies with P/B ratio < 1 to disclose what they are doing to increase it to above 1, while urging company execs to manage their capital better.

On a price-to-book basis (P/B), Japanese equities do look cheap compared to other global developed equity markets.

The Japan TOPIX index is trading at just 1.4x book value, which is more than two-thirds lower than the US.

There are many reasons why the Japanese market has such a low P/B value, including years of poor capital allocation that had led to massive over-capitalisation.

“Indeed, there are a lot of companies listed in Japan with P/B ratios below one,” said Schroders.

“That means there are lots of companies with the potential to be revalued more highly – if they can convince investors that they should be.”

Now read: Orbis is so very Big on Japan: Here’s why they reckon the world’s No 2 developed market is fun again

So what is P/B, and why is it important for investors?

The P/B ratio is a financial metric that compares a company’s stock price to its book value per share.

Price Book Ratio = Share price/Book value per share

Book value meanwhile is the difference between a company’s assets and liabilities, or simply its shareholders’ equity.

Another way to look at book value is that it’s the total value that would be left over, according to the company’s balance sheet, if it goes bankrupt immediately.

A P/B ratio of less than 1 could indicate an inefficient use of capital, and that the market believes the company is worth more dead than alive (i.e. worth more liquidated than operating). This might be because investors have a very sceptical view of the company’s future profitability and growth.

But on the other hand, a P/B ratio of lower than 1 could also mean the stock price is undervalued.

For bargain hunters, this is very important as buying a stock for less than its book value allows a certain “margin of safety”.

Word of caution:

Although the P/B ratio could be useful to identify undervalued stocks, it is mostly used for mature companies with high capital-intensive businesses such as large energy, transportation, or manufacturers. Basically, those with many liquid and tangible assets on the books.

It can be misleading to use P/B ratio on firms with significant R&D expenditure like small biotechs, service companies, or those with high debt or negative earnings.

Warren Buffett meanwhile has always maintained that he isn’t a big fan of using book value to gauge a company’s worth.

In the 2000 annual meeting of Berkshire shareholders, Buffett said:

“The very best businesses, the really wonderful businesses, require no book value.

“We want to buy a businesses, really, that will deliver more and more cash and not need to retain cash, which is what builds up book value over time.”

Indeed there are other metrics to find undervalued stocks outside of Price-to-Book value, such as Price-to-Earnings (P/E) and Price-to-Sales (P/S).

ASX Large and Medium Caps with P/B Ratio < 1

Source: Commsec

Code	Name	Price-Book Ratio (P/B)
SGR	The Star Entertainment	0.3
VUK	Virgin Money UK PLC	0.46
CMW	Cromwell Property Group	0.53
BOQ	Bank of Queensland	0.57
MGF	Magellan Global Fund	0.59
GOZ	Growthpoint Properties	0.61
DXS	Dexus	0.64
CLW	Charter Hall Long Wale REIT	0.66
CQE	Charter Hall Social Infrastructure REIT	0.7
GPT	GPT Group	0.71
CIP	Centuria Industrial REIT	0.74
CQR	Charter Hall Retail REIT	0.76
HDN	HomeCo Daily Needs REIT	0.76
BEN	Bendigo and Adelaide Bank	0.77
RRL	Regis Resources	0.77
SCG	Scentre Group	0.78
AMP	AMP	0.79
IFL	Insignia Financial	0.79
VCX	Vicinity Centres	0.81
MGR	Mirvac Group	0.82
YAL	Yancoal Australia	0.82
LLC	Lendlease Group	0.83
WPR	Waypoint REIT	0.84
LFS	Latitude Group	0.84
TPG	TPG Telecom	0.85
HLS	Healius	0.86
TAH	Tabcorp Holdings	0.86
NUF	Nufarm	0.91
CNI	Centuria Capital Group	0.91
HLI	Helia Group	0.91
BWP	BWP Trust	0.93
IPL	Incitec Pivot	0.93

Some ASX Small Caps with P/B Ratio < 1

Source: Commsec

Code	Name	Price-Book Ratio (P/B)
MSB	Mesoblast	0.42
CMO	Cosmo Metals	0.42
OXT	Orexplore Technologies	0.42
ENT	Enterprise Metals	0.43
AL8	Alderan Resources	0.43
DM1	Desert Metals	0.43
TVL	Touch Ventures	0.43
HAS	Hastings Technology Metals	0.43
B4P	Beforepay	0.71
UVA	Uvre	0.71
IPC	Imperial Pacific	0.72
WML	Woomera Mining	0.72
AMA	Ama	0.72
CDM	Cadence Capital	0.72
BCI	BCI Minerals	0.72
ZIP	Zip Co	0.72
PFE	Pantera Minerals	0.72
TRP	Tissue Repair Ltd	0.72
VTX	Vertex Minerals	0.72
NFL	Norfolk Metals	0.72
IMC	Immuron	0.73
BLZ	Blaze Minerals	0.73
RND	Rand Mining	0.73
KBC	Keybridge Capital	0.73
MYX	Mayne Pharma	0.73
VTI	Visioneering Technologies Inc	0.73
GDA	Good Drinks Australia Ltd	0.93
CYP	Cynata Therapeutics	0.93
EVS	EnviroSuite	0.93
RCL	ReadCloud	0.93
MHK	Metal Hawk	0.93
OZM	OzAurum Resources	0.93
OM1	Omnia Metals	0.93
BPH	BPH Energy Ltd	0.94